|
KMID : 1021220100010010065
|
|
국제물리치료학회지
2010 Volume.1 No. 1 p.65 ~ p.72
|
|
|
A Comparison of the Results from Somatotype Evaluation with Different Evaluation Tools
|
|
Choi Wan-Suk
Choi Jung-Hyun
Cho Mi-Suk
Moon Ok-Kon
Park Joo-Hyun
Chung Hyung-Kuk
Lee Suk-Hee
Lee Jung-Sook
Min Kyung-Ok
|
|
|
Abstract
|
|
|
|
Supposing that somatotype evaluation results would have significant differences between the public group with less amounts of exercises and the special group with intensive exercises for three to four times a day, this study aimed at comparing the mutual consistency between the results determined by somatotype evaluation tools such as visually calculated index(VCI), Rohrer’s Index(RI) and Body Mass Index(BMI). The public, taekwondo players and judo players groups were composed of fifty persons, taekwondo players and judo players passed through VCI determination, respectively. Their height and weight were examined and analyzed with somatotype evaluation tools. Comparison of somatotype dispersion of RI and VCI showed that most women were determined by VCI as lean type but were determined by RI as normal type. And that women were determined by VCI as fat type but were determined by RI as normal type. Therefore both men and women showed significant differences in VCI and RI. Comparison of somatotype dispersion of VCI and BMI showed that both men and women were overestimated or underestimated by VCI rather than by BMI. Comparison of somatotype dispersion of RI and BMI showed that men were less determined by BMI as lean type compared with women; both men and women less determined by BMI rather than by RI as normal type; and both men and women, in particular, were more determined by BMI as fat type but men were more determined by BMI rather than by RI as fat type. Total somatotype consistency by tools showed that VCI has the greatest possibility of determining the public group, compared with other groups as lean type and that the consistency of the three tools were relatively higher for the taekwondo players and judo players groups, compared with the public.
|
|
|
KEYWORD
|
|
|
Body Mass Index(BMI), Rohrer’s Index(RI), Somatotype, Visually Calculated Index(VCI)
|
|
|
FullTexts / Linksout information
|
|
|
|
|
Listed journal information
|
|
|